Pickerify vs IGComments: how many comments the free export actually delivers
A free limit says how big a post a tool will accept, not how many comments end up in your file. We tested both on the same posts and counted the rows.
Updated Nov 16, 2026 · 5 min read
The short answer
On 16 November 2026 we exported three public Instagram posts with Pickerify's free Instagram comment export. The posts had 346, 780 and 972 comments. The files held 62, 52 and 42 comments, and no replies. The page reported “Comments ready” each time and did not show how many comments were in the file.
IGComments exports every comment and reply on a post with up to 200 comments for free, shows the number it read next to the number Instagram reports, and on a bigger post shows the first 200 free and the price for the rest before you pay.
The test
We chose three public posts that IGComments' sister tool had already read in full, so the true number of public comments was known. We pasted each link into Pickerify's free export as a visitor with no account, waited for “Comments ready”, and counted the rows in the JSON file.
| Comments on the post | Rows in Pickerify's free file | Different people in it | Replies in it | IGComments, free | IGComments, with a pass |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 346 | 62 (18%) | 28 | 0 | First 200, with the count shown | All 346 ($4.99) |
| 780 | 52 (7%) | 3 | 0 | First 200, with the count shown | All 780 ($4.99) |
| 972 | 42 (4%) | 19 | 0 | First 200, with the count shown | All public comments, 970 when we read it ($4.99) |
The row count did not grow with the size of the post: the biggest post produced the smallest file. We tested the free tier only; we did not buy a Pickerify pass, so we can't say how many comments a paid export contains.
Why the free file is short
Pickerify says so itself, in small print. Its terms, pricing page and FAQ state that each draw or export “reads comments for a set time” and that “paid plans read longer”; its FAQ puts the free reading time at about 20 seconds. Reading the comments on an Instagram post takes one request per page of comments and another for each reply thread, so a fixed reading time covers the first few pages and stops.
That makes “free up to 1,000 comments” a limit on which posts are accepted, not a promise of 1,000 rows. Nothing about this is hidden, but the export page does not show a count, so the only way to notice is to open the file and compare it with the post.
Side by side
| IGComments | Pickerify export | |
|---|---|---|
| Stated free limit | Posts up to 200 comments | Posts up to 1,000 comments |
| Comments delivered free, 346-comment post | 200 | 62 |
| Comments delivered free, 972-comment post | 200 | 42 |
| How reading is limited | By count: every comment up to the limit | By time: a set reading time, longer on paid plans |
| Count shown before you download | Yes: comments read and Instagram's reported count | No |
| Replies | Included, each linked to its parent comment | Advertised; none in our three free files |
| One-time pass | $4.99 up to 2,000 comments, then larger passes | $4.99 up to 15,000 · $9.99 up to 50,000 · $14.99 up to 200,000 |
| Formats | CSV, Excel (XLSX), JSON | CSV, Excel (XLSX), JSON |
| Login | None | None |
Pickerify figures are from its public pages on 16 November 2026 and our own test that day. Prices and limits change; check theirs before deciding.
How to check any exporter in one minute
- Note the comment count Instagram shows on the post.
- Export the post and open the file.
- Count the rows. In Excel or Google Sheets, select the first column and read the count in the status bar.
- Expect a little under Instagram’s number, because it includes deleted, hidden and spam-filtered comments that no tool can read. See why the Instagram comment count doesn’t match.
- If the file holds a small fraction of the post, the tool stopped early. For a giveaway that means most entrants are missing from the list.
To see the full list for your own post, paste the link on the IGComments home page. The other exporters are compared on Instagram comment export tools compared.
FAQ
Does Pickerify export 1,000 Instagram comments for free?
It accepts posts with up to 1,000 comments for free, but its free export reads comments for a set time (about 20 seconds, according to its FAQ). In our test on 16 November 2026, posts with 346, 780 and 972 comments produced files with 62, 52 and 42 comments.
Does IGComments export every comment?
Yes. IGComments reads every public comment and reply on the post and shows the number it read next to the number Instagram reports. Posts with up to 200 comments are free; bigger posts use a one-time Export Pass from $4.99. Deleted, hidden and spam-filtered comments are not public and no tool can read them.
How do I know if my export is complete?
Count the rows in the file and compare with the comment count on the post. A complete export is usually a little under Instagram’s number. A file with a small fraction of it was cut short.
Is a bigger free limit better?
Only if the tool reads the whole post. A limit describes which posts are accepted. What matters is the number of rows in the file, and whether the tool tells you that number.