Instagram Reel comments vs feed post comments: what differs when you export
Reels and feed posts feel different in the app, but their comments export the same way. The differences that matter are in how you read the data, not in how you get it.
Updated Nov 17, 2026 · 6 min read
What is identical
A Reel, a single photo and a carousel each have their own link, and each has one comment section. Paste any of them into IGComments and you get the same file: one row per comment or reply, with username, comment, posted_at_utc, likes, is_reply, reply_to_username, mentions, hashtags, comment_id and user_id, plus the parent comment ID for replies. The search, the filters and the stats panel work the same on all three, and so do the CSV, Excel and JSON downloads.
Links with tracking parameters at the end work for all of them. Collab Reels and collab posts have one shared comment section, and that is the one exported. Only public posts can be exported. See exporting Reel comments for the Reel-specific steps.
What to read differently
The data is the same shape, but the audience behaves differently, so the same filter tells you different things. These are patterns to check on your own posts, not rules.
- Comment volume over time. Posts often collect most of their comments soon after posting. A Reel can keep receiving comments for longer if it keeps being shown to new people. Chart the timestamps (see timestamps and time zones) and compare the shape for your own account instead of assuming either.
- Who is commenting. A Reel can reach people who do not follow the account. Comments from strangers tend to be shorter, more emoji-heavy and more likely to be questions or reactions than conversation. Check the share of emoji-only comments and the share of replies in each export.
- Replies. A feed post from an account with a loyal community has more back-and-forth in reply threads. Compare the reply share:
=COUNTIF(H2:H5000,"yes")/COUNTA(H2:H5000), which works in Excel and Google Sheets. - Language. Reels that travel can pick up comments in several languages. The export keeps emoji and non-English text intact. Search for a few common words in each language to see the mix.
Questions that fit each format
- Reels: “What did people ask about the product in the video?” Filter to questions, then read for repeats. Reels with a recipe, tutorial or product often prompt “where do I get this” or “what song is this” type comments. See questions and buying intent.
- Feed photo posts: “Who showed up to the giveaway?” Photos and carousels are the common format for entry posts, so giveaway exports are usually from these.
- Carousels: “Which slide got the reaction?” Not in the data directly; see the carousel page for how to search for slide references.
Comparing a Reel with a post
To compare formats fairly, export one of each, paste both into one sheet and add a column format with the value reel or post. Then:
- Comments per unique commenter: count rows, and count distinct usernames (
=COUNTA(UNIQUE(C2:C5000))in Excel 365 and Google Sheets). - Reply share, as above.
- Average likes per comment:
=AVERAGE(G2:G5000). - Questions: filter on the results page before exporting, or search the text for “?”.
Compare posts with similar reach and age. A Reel from last week and a photo from last year are not a fair pair, and a post with 40 comments gives you a pattern at best. For detail on counting people rather than comments, see counting unique commenters.
Same limits on both
The count Instagram shows includes comments it does not serve to anyone, on Reels as well as posts, so a complete export is typically smaller than the displayed number. The results page shows the comments read next to the count Instagram reports. Up to 200 comments per post are free; above that, a one-time pass applies, and very large posts are collected in the background over one to three days with an email when ready. Stories and Lives are not supported. Why not.
FAQ
Is the export different for a Reel than for a photo post?
No. The columns, filters, stats and formats are the same. Only the link differs.
Can I export comments from a Reel I did not post?
Yes, if it is public. You do not need to own the post or log in to Instagram.
Do Reels get more comments from non-followers?
Often, but it depends on the account and the Reel. Check the commenters and reply share in your own exports rather than assuming.
Are replies included for Reels?
Yes. Replies are exported for every post type and linked to the comment they answer.
Does a Reel that is also a collab post export?
Yes. A collab has one shared comment section, and that is what is exported.